Justice Without Borders: Virtual Courtrooms and the Institutionalization of Digital Access in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa

Justice Without Borders: Virtual
Courtrooms and the Institutionalization of Digital Access in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
By Saleem Shah Hoti
For decades, the corridors of our district courts have borne silent witness to a quiet tragedy: the physical, mental, and financial exhaustion of the ordinary litigant. In a justice system bound by nineteenth-century procedural formalities, the mere act of securing one’s "presence” in a courtroom often became a punishment far harsher than any final decree. However, a landmark shift in judicial philosophy—crystallized by the recent judgment of Peshawar High Court Chief Justice S. M. Attique Shah and followed swiftly by the formulation of Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) by District and Sessions Judges across Khyber Pakhtunkhwa alongside the installation of modern audiovisual apparatus in court premises—marks a transformative milestone toward humane, accessible, and efficient justice.
”By recognizing ‘constructive presence’ through interactive video link and operationalizing it through district-level SOPs, the judiciary has ensured that modern technology serves not as an intrusion upon the rule of law, but as an indispensable instrument for citizen dignity.”
At the heart of this institutional reform is the progressive interpretation of Section 353 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (CrPC), read harmoniously with Section 540-A CrPC and the substituted Article 164 of the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order, 1984 (QSO). In Qazi Aslam Sanjrani vs. Niaz Ali & others (Cr.M Transfer Application No. 49-P/2026), Chief Justice S. M. Attique Shah examined the predicament of a wheelchair-bound cardiac patient residing in Karachi who faced severe medical hardship, security threats, and exhausting overland journeys to attend trial proceedings in Lakki Marwat. Rather than insisting on rigid physical attendance, the Court reaffirmed a vital constitutional principle: Section 353 CrPC is designed as a procedural safeguard for the accused—to remain informed of evidence, instruct counsel, and ensure a fair trial—not as an instrument of logistical attrition.
To anchor this progressive vision in settled law, Chief Justice Attique Shah synthesized a comprehensive body of superior court jurisprudence:
Foundational Exemption & Constructive Presence: While noting the principles governing personal attendance exemptions laid down by the Supreme Court in Haji Aurangzeb v. Mushtaq Ahmad (PLD 2004 SC 160) and applied by the Peshawar High Court in Sajjad Akbar v. The State (2022 MLD 1325), the Court highlighted how technological advancement has expanded the concept of "presence” under Section 353 CrPC to include "constructive presence”. This doctrine was articulated by the Peshawar High Court Division Bench in Muhammad Israr v. The State (PLD 2021 Peshawar 105), echoed by the Lahore High Court in Munawar Hussain and another v. The State (2020 PCr.LJ 1184), and reinforced by the Islamabad High Court in Abdul Qadar Ahsan v. Additional Deputy Commissioner (G), Islamabad and another (PLD 2019 Islamabad 434).
The Apex Court’s Definitive Seal: The Supreme Court of Pakistan cemented virtual attendance as a valid species of open-court appearance in Meesha Shafi v. Ali Zafar (PLD 2023 SC 211)—also drawing upon principles from the Aijazur Rehman case of the Sindh High Court and the Praful Desai judgment of the Indian Supreme Court—holding that interactive video conferencing allows the judge and parties to see and hear witnesses in real time without unnecessary diplomatic or logistical delays. Similarly, in Salman Akram Raja and another v. Government of Punjab and others (2013 SCMR 203), the Apex Court endorsed video-link recording to protect vulnerable victims from courtroom trauma.
Contemporary Affirmations & Statutory Boundaries: Following Meesha Shafi, the Peshawar High Court in Shah Agha v. The State (2025 P CrLJ 523) and the Lahore High Court in Zubaida Khanam v. The State (PLD 2026 Lahore 493) reaffirmed that video-link proceedings must be actively encouraged where no tangible prejudice is caused. At the same time, Chief Justice Attique Shah carefully delineated statutory boundaries by citing the Islamabad High Court in Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi v. Federation of Pakistan and others (W.P. No. 839/2023) and the Lahore High Court Division Bench in Imran Ahmad Khan Niazi v. Government of the Punjab (PLD 2025 Lahore 795). These rulings clarify that while virtual participation is permissible during trial proceedings, mandatory physical production remains strictly required for physical remand under Article 10(2) of the Constitution, Section 167 CrPC, and Section 21-E of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997, as well as at initial and final pre-arrest bail hearings, receipt of documents under Section 265-C CrPC, and signing pleas or statements under Section 342 CrPC unless specifically dispensed with under strict judicial scrutiny.
Crucially, the true triumph of Qazi Aslam Sanjrani lies in its immediate institutional translation on the ground. In direct compliance with the judgment of Chief Justice S. M. Attique Shah, District and Sessions Judges across Khyber Pakhtunkhwa have formulated comprehensive Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) to regulate and streamline virtual court operations. Simultaneously, the widespread installation of video cameras, dedicated virtual booths, and audiovisual equipment across court premises has turned judicial theory into accessible reality for litigants, witnesses, and lawyers alike.
These district-level SOPs are indispensable because, as the Chief Justice cautioned, virtual participation is neither an automatic right nor devoid of risk. In an era of rapid advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) and digital impersonation, standardized protocols ensure rigorous identity verification, secure two-way communication, protection against witness coaching, and effective judicial supervision.
This coordinated leap—combining enlightened constitutional jurisprudence with practical courtroom infrastructure and standardized provincial SOPs—is a profoundly positive and encouraging step. It saves precious time, conserves public and private energy, and spares citizens immense physical discomfort and mental anguish. When an ailing litigant can pursue justice without risking their health, a witness can testify without fear, and counsel can argue efficiently across districts, the courts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa demonstrate how a legal system can faithfully honor both the letter of the statute and the dignity of the citizen.
Saleem Shah Hoti is an advocate and legal commentator based in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, writing regularly on constitutional jurisprudence, judicial reform, and social justice.



